Originally published by: Palladium Books
Originally published in: TMNT & Other Strangeness
Publication date: November, 1985
Script/Pencils/Inks: Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird
Lettering: Peter Laird
“Don’t Judge a Book…”
At April’s apartment, the Turtles are putting the finishing touches on their Halloween costumes: Mike is dressed as a clown, Leo is dressed like an Alien, Raph is dressed like a punk rockstar and Don is dressed like an old lady. They give April a call and she (dressed like a jungle girl) tells them to come over to the Halloween party at around nine o’clock.
Outside, a gang of thugs case the Second Time Around shop to see if it’s an easy break-in. One thug knocks on the door, looking for “Chet”, and finds only an old lady (Don) home. The thugs decide to take the place and break in through the downstairs.
The Turtles hear them coming a mile away, however, and quickly defend the joint. A short brawl ensues and the thugs go down for the count. Unfortunately, however, the fight completely ruined their Halloween costumes.
At the party, April wonders if her friends will buy her story that it’s her four “southern cousins” that are dropping by. Suddenly, the door opens and in step all four Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles… sans costumes. That isn’t a problem, however, as everyone at the party just assumes they’re in costumes anyway and compliment them on their look.
*This story was reprinted in the “Shell Shock” trade paperback.
*CHET ALERT: The thug scoping out April’s apartment asks “Is Chet here?” The name “Chet” was an in-joke used in numerous Mirage TMNT comics because the guys at the office… just liked the name!
*Among the costumed party-goers are Spider-Man, Wonder Woman, Superman, Darth Vader, Batgirl, the Thing, Megaton Man, Etrigan the Demon, Mr. Spock, Thor, Zorro and Popeye.
Hard to muster up any vitriol or dull praise for this story, as its neither good nor bad, but simply there.
Very Zen, come to think of it.
I don’t actually own any of the Palladium RPG sourcebooks that a lot of these short comics were published in. I’m not really sure what the point of publishing the comics in a tabletop RPG sourcebook was; maybe to get the juices flowing in the imaginations of the people playing the game? For stories like “Road Hogs” and “Terror by Transmat”, it certainly seems that way. “Hey, here’s a look at the theme of this sourcebook and an idea of one of the kinds of plotlines you could come up with!”
But “Don’t Judge a Book”? I mean, to those of you out there who spent the 80s playing tabletop RPGs, did you ever feel compelled to create a storyline where your characters dressed like old ladies and beat up burglars?
Jeez, just go play Dungeons or Dragons or something.
Anyhow, “Don’t Judge a Book” is entirely forgettable save maybe for all the copyright infringement going on at the Halloween party. That’s sort of amusing, I guess, especially if you read the costumed partygoers in the voices of their costume identities. I mean, when else are you going to get to see Popeye interact with the Ninja Turtles?
Grade: M (as in, “Meh. Just Meh.”)