Wednesday, August 24, 2011

TMNT (IDW) #1



Publication date: August 24, 2011

Story: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz
Script: Tom Waltz
Layouts: Kevin Eastman
Art: Dan Duncan
Colors: Ronda Pattison
Letters: Robbie Robbins
Editor: Scott Dunbier
Associate editor: Bobby Curnow

Summary:

On an abandoned street in a bad part of New York, Splinter, Leonardo, Donatello and Michelangelo face-off against mutant cat and long-time foe of Splinter’s, Old Hob, and his gang of thugs. Splinter tries to talk Hob out of battle, but the feline is insistent on finally putting Splinter and his reptile sons in the ground. And so a fight breaks out, though Splinter orders the Turtles to refrain from killing. They make short work of the thugs, while Splinter brings down Hob. Swearing that Splinter and his sons will disappear “just like that other stinkin’ freak”, Hob escapes into the alleys. Hob’s words cut Splinter and the Turtles deep, as they remember Raphael, who is out somewhere, alone and destitute.



Eighteen months earlier, at the Stockgen Research lab, intern April O’Neil is being shown around the place by the nervous Chet. Chet introduces her to four turtles, which she immediately finds captivatingly adorable, as well as the pet lab rat, whom they let roam free because they can’t keep him locked in his cage (a notion that doesn’t sit well with the rat-hating April).



In the office of the lab’s owner, Baxter Stockman, the unscrupulous doctor gets a phone call from his benefactor, the enigmatic General Krang. Calling from his island fortress, and irritated at the distraction from the war he’s been waging, Krang demands to know why Stockman is past due on the results of his projects. Stockman assures him that progress in the terrapin/human exo-armor synthesis and rodentia psychotropic serum have only met with a minor delay. Likewise, the super-soldier mutagen is coming along swimmingly. Stockman promises to hand-deliver the results to Krang as soon as they’re ready.



Three months later (so fifteen months ago), April asks the other lab assistant, Lindsey, why they named the rat “Splinter”. Lindsey explains that it’s a reference to the psychotropic drug they’re testing on him, which “splinters” the human-like cognition powers from the instinctual animal nature. April is livid at the idea of psychotropic drug tests, as she thought she was helping to engineer livestock to stop world hunger. Chet quickly distracts her by asking what she’s named the four turtles. April tells him that she was inspired by her History of Renaissance Art 101 class to name them Leonardo, Donatello, Michelangelo and Raphael.



Speaking of Raphael, back in the present, Raph is busy climbing through dumpsters, eating discarded pizza crusts. Digging through suburban garbage for anything useful (finding only a tacky “Cowabunga” t-shirt), Raph hears the siren song of domestic abuse. He peeks through a window and sees a drunken father pummeling his teenage son, Casey. Not about to sit idly by, Raph breaks the front door down and barges in.


Turtle Tips:

*The story continues in TMNT (IDW) #2.

*General Krang will return in TMNT (IDW) #7.

*"Chet" was also the name of the young boy who bought the turtles from a pet shop in the original Mirage comic book series.

*An ashcan edition was released a few weeks prior to TMNT (IDW) #1’s proper release as a promotional item containing 8 pages of the full issue.

*This issue was released with a whopping 13 variant covers: Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo and Donatello covers plus a gatefold cover connecting them all by Dan Duncan, incentive cover, sketch cover and ashcan edition cover by Kevin Eastman, a Sam Kieth cover and exclusive covers for Jetpack Comics (Peter Laird), NECRA/Larry’s Comics (Dan Duncan), Detroit Fanfare/Wonderworld Comics (Dan Duncan) and Hastings Entertainment (Dan Duncan). Holy shit.

*CHET ALERT: April’s boss at Stockgen Research is named Chet Allen. The name “Chet” was an in-joke used by the Mirage staff in several issues of the original series because… they just liked the name!


Review:

This is very exciting for me.

You see, I’ve never had the luxury of following a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comic from month to month as it keeps a forward-moving narrative. I was an X-Men kid growing up, so my allowance in the 90s always went to the X-books at the newsstand, never any of Archie’s TMNT Adventures titles. I didn’t have a local comic shop back then, either, so the Mirage or Image titles were never available to me. By the time I finally got wise and started following TMNT Vol. 4, Laird put the book on indefinite hiatus (this was in 2006) and that was that. I did have the fortune of following Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 2) from beginning to end, but that was an anthology series that hopped all over the established Mirage timeline and offered very few chronological stories.

Honestly, this brand new series from IDW is the first monthly Ninja Turtles book with a story that moves forward I have ever followed. And I am giddy.

But that bit of stupid anecdotal nonsense aside, IDW’s TMNT #1 may not go down in history as the stuff of funny book legends like Mirage’s TMNT #1, but for long-term Turtle fans with open minds about the many incarnations of the franchise from the past twenty-five years, I think it’s gotten to a very intriguing start.

In the current comic book industry, “decompression” is the name of the game; seeing how many issues you can possibly spread a single plot over in order to wring the most money from the reader. So with contemporary trends in mind, TMNT #1 doesn’t offer a complete origin story for us, opting to deliver it in piecemeal and through leap-frogging flashbacks. So if you grabbed this issue off the rack for the modern (absurd) price of $4 bucks, expecting a complete story, then you may want to jump into your Delorean and travel back twenty years when comics still did that sorta thing. Here, author Tom Waltz uses this first issue to let all the various plot threads loose, to be sewn up as things move along.

Personally, I’m fine with the method of decompression so long as it isn’t employed to ridiculous extents (Donatello: The Brain Thief immediately comes to mind). And using a first issue simply as a means to open up a can of plot threads isn’t such a bad thing when those plot threads are genuinely intriguing and have me anxious for 30 days to go by.

How does Splinter know Old Hob? Does April know the Turtles are mutants? How did they mutate? Why is Raph a runaway? That’s Casey Jones at the end, right? Holy shit, did you say KRANG!?

All this and more and I wanna know allllll about it.

What pleases me most is that Waltz (and co-plotter Kevin Eastman, I guess) chose to open with “the story already in progress” so that we could get some Ninja Turtle action early on, giving us the first chunk of the origin via flashback. The alternative would have been to give us the whole origin from the very beginning and not have the mutated Turtles show up until the last page (spewing some trite cliffhanger dialogue, I’m sure), which is something a lot of comics do that I’m pretty well sick of. Hell, if Brian Michael Bendis had written this we wouldn’t see a single Ninja Turtle until issue #5. The execution of seeding the origin out throughout a current plotline is reminiscent of how the original TMNT (Vol. 1) #1 opened and is all the better for it.

To get back to my dumb anecdotes, I just want to admit that like many people my age, my introduction to the TMNT came from the Fred Wolf cartoon. I didn’t find out about the original comics until I was a teenager. So even though the Fred Wolf cartoon is a series that has not aged well at all and can be nearly impossible to endure 95% of the time, I still hold a firm grip on the characters and ideas born from it. I stand by the old adage that “there are no bad characters, just bad writers” (though not steadfastly, mind you), and while guys like Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady may have been silly and ineffectual in a syndicated children’s cartoon from 1987, that doesn’t mean they should be written off as “garbage” never to be used again. A good writer can take these characters, boil them down to their essential elements, deduce what makes them work and then implement them in a modern and intelligent manner.

I have absolutely no idea if Waltz is going to be doing that with “General Krang”, but I am psyched to find out if he does.

My point, though, is that I love the Fred Wolf/Archie/Playmates characters with all their stupid quirks and faults and I am ready to see them all again, rejuvenated by new writers with fresh ideas and modern storytelling skills. And I have money. Just… take it, IDW.

Dan Duncan’s artwork covers Kevin Eastman’s layouts and I do dig the guy’s style. He occasionally seems to interpret the TMNT’s trademarked sneer as a massive “overbite”, and especially so on the covers (where he’s received quite a bit of criticism), but it’s hardly a consistent thing and I never found it distracting in the interior art. His characters are very expressive, but most importantly, he’s capable of drawing both mutants and humans well. Much of the time, TMNT gets artists that are either/or and it shows. I suppose if I had one problem, it would be that he draws the Turtles with pupil-less eyes even when they aren’t wearing their bandanas. Now, yes, I know that the idea that their pupils magically vanish once they put a strip of fabric on their faces is nonsense, but Raph just looks creepy and weird with the white, milky eyes and no bandana. It’s a design aesthetic I’ve never seen an artist use on the Turtles before, which might be why it stood out to me.

Some of Eastman’s layouts are published in the back of the book under the “Ninja Notes” editorial/letters column. From what I can tell, there was some give and take between Eastman’s layouts and Duncan’s finished pencils. Eastman’s page 1 gave the towering skyscrapers some warping curvature that gave the opening shot a dynamic and bizarre touch, while Duncan went with just normal architecture that, while perfectly fine, doesn’t visually pop and grab you quite as well. On the other hand, Duncan improves on a lot of Splinter’s poses, as Eastman went with a rather bland “face-forward, snout-down” look. In the end, though, I like what Duncan’s done and he was definitely a good choice for the title.

Like a lot of modern comics that cost almost as much as your lunch, it reads very quickly and you may not feel like you got a whole lot of story for $4 bucks. These days, singles are really just for the hardcore fans that have to follow a monthly narrative as it progresses and don’t mind blowing the extra cash. With the economy the way it is and comic book prices steadily rising to ever-ridiculous heights, waiting for the trade has become the wiser option and one I’ve been selecting more frequently than ever before.

However, for Ninja Turtles, I make an exception. And with the interesting twists on the classic origin that Waltz and Eastman are going with, as well as cryptic glimpses of certain characters I never thought I’d see in a TMNT comic again, this is a book I absolutely have to follow every 30 days and I can tell from just the first issue. If Waltz, Eastman and IDW can keep this up, they’ve got my $4 bucks.

Grade: B (as in, “But 13 variant covers? Really? What is this, 1994 or something?”)

11 comments:

Encapuchadoman said...

So, this new collection is the Volume 5 of the story or is it another thing?

And all the stories of the Image volume are non-canon?

Mark Pellegrini said...

@Encapuchadoman,

You could call it "Vol. 5", but I opted not to since it has no connection to the Mirage series and I didn't want to confuse anyone.

The Image series (Vol. 3) was originally written as a continuation of the Mirage series Vol. 1 and Vol. 2, but was retconned out of canon by Vol. 4.

Aside from the open ending, however, Vol. 3 is surprisingly non-contradictory to Vol. 4, and official author Gary Carlson along with scripter Andrew Modeen have been rectifying that with their 2-part conclusion to the series. The first part (#24) is out with the second part (#25) currently in the inking process and nearing completion.

Encapuchadoman said...

So, who is publishing this 2-part conclusion, Image?

I have to ask all this things because I'm spanish and all this material it never came to my country in an official way. So I'm a little bit conffused with all the volumes and stuff.

Also, sorry for my english. Like I said, I talk spanish...

Mark Pellegrini said...

@Encapuchadoman

TMNT (Vol. 3) #24 and #25 were pitched to Viacom (the current owners of TMNT) by Gary Carlson, Frank Fosco and Erik Larsen (the writer, artist and editor of the Image series, respectively) but Viacom declined to grant them the license.

So scripter Andrew Modeen and artist Arseniy Dubakov, who were working with the three Image creators, opted to self-publish it as an unofficial publication.

It has all the official creators from the Image series contributing to it, but it is not officially licensed by Viacom.

You can read more about that in my review for TMNT (Vol. 3) #24 here:

http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/05/tmnt-vol-3-24.html

And no worries about the English; it seems fine to me!

Encapuchadoman said...

Ok, I'll read this review. Thank you so much for your help.

Ian S said...

Great review! It kinda struck me that you counted this as a decompressed story, because I felt it flowed very well and a lot was covered and introduced. I guess it's that I just came off of JL#1, a reboot that doesn't take any risks, introduces little, plods along slowly, and doesn't raise any intriguing questions, while I was just as excited as you are at Krang, Casey, the mystery of what comes between the origin and the present day, and all of it.

Looking forward to the rest of the story!

peter schaaff said...

Thanks for you indeep work and investigations on TMNT comic books and stuff.

Matthew LeDrew said...

I think we have very different artistic preferences, sir. Which is fine. Hope you don't have an issue with me posting my blog links into your comments like this... I'm actually a huge fan of what you do!

I actually have a question not to do with this post: I notice if the Mirage reviews you're only reviewing the titles that Laird said were "canon". Is this the case? Are you eventually going to review them all? Just curious.

Here's my thoughts on this issue, for anyone who wants to check it out. http://matthewledrew.wordpress.com/2012/02/17/an-addition-my-thoughts-on-idws-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-1/

Mark Pellegrini said...

@Matthew LeDrew

Nah, it's cool, man. I don't mind!

As for Mirage, I do plan on doing them all eventually, but I'm just going through the " Laird canon" ones first for the sake of keeping the narrative steady. Though I ought to go back and do The River even if it isn't "Laird canon".

Gil Machado said...

Another great review Mark, spot on as always. And yes you should most def do the River trilogy, very interested on your thoughts on that particular story. Keep up the great work!

Bernie said...

Yea, id like to see more reviews of volume 4 since the latest issue was published may 2014 but I understand reviews take time, I love every blog ive read of yours so far which is a lot. I am a huge tmnt fan and have learned a lot from your reviews and the mirage continuity timeline!